|

Council Members Refuse To Back Away From Public Protest of Mayoral Nominee

While members of the audience held up signs of protest against Albert McWilliams’s proposed appointment to the Ann Arbor Downtown Development Authority, Ward 3 Council member Stephen Kunselman, Ward 1 Council member Sumi Kailasapathy and Ward 5 Council member Mike Anglin all raised objections when it came time for City Council to approve the minutes from the September 16th meeting at which John Hieftje pushed through McWilliams’s appointment while violating Council Rules. At the October 7th meeting, DDA Board appointee Albert McWilliams was, once again, the point of contention. At the September 3rd meeting, McWilliams’s proposed appointment was met with stiff resistance  on the part of five Council members, all of whom found McWilliams candidacy singularly unacceptable. The reason? McWillaims’s personal website and his Twitter account contained material, including photos, that several Council members saw as degrading to woman.

On September 3rd, Hieftje asked to withdraw McWilliams’s nomination. The minutes prepared by the City Clerk, however, did not reflect that fact. At issue was whether the appointment had been postponed on September 3rd (which would have required a vote) or withdrawn.

At issue, really, is whether John Hieftje has enough Milk of Magnesia stockpiled to get him through the next year.

As Kunselman suggested the minutes be changed to read that the mayor “pretended to postpone” the request for confirmation of the McWilliams appointment, shocked laughter rippled through the audience. Ward 1 Council member Sabra Briere did her best to explain to Council members what the mayor actually meant to say on September 3rd, while Hieftje looked increasingly dyspeptic. Ward 5 Council member Warpehoski suggested that Kunselman was engaging in “political theater.” Ward 4 Council member Margie Teall honest-to-Dog “remembered” Hieftje saying he’d postponed the proposed appointment on September 3rd.

Steve Kunselman, not waiting to be recognized by Hieftje, shot back at Teall that had the McWilliams nomination been postponed, Council would have voted on the postponement. “We didn’t vote,” he said, speaking calmly. His point was simple: In bringing the appointment back and requesting a vote the same evening on the 16th of September, Hieftje’s proposed candidate McWilliams had to have eight votes (he only got six) for confirmation, according to Council Rules.

Sabra Briere then asked for “advice” from the City Attorney. The City Attorney, his fingers burning from the hot potato, said it was a matter of parliamentary procedure and so was up to Council’s interpretation of those rules.

All in all, it was an unprecedented effort by City Council members Kailasapathy, Lumm, Kunselman and Anglin to show the public that they are prepared to demand open, honest, transparent government and hold proposed appointees to high standards. Hieftje appointee, Julie Weatherbee, grudgingly agreed as she live Tweeted the meeting that Council members should do research and ask questions about mayoral appointees:

In short, for John Hieftje it was the equivalent of Mexican food at 3 a.m. Take a slug of Pepto to wash down  the Tums.

The end to the French Farce that is Albert McWilliams’s proposed appointment to the DDA is around the corner. Come November 7th, Ward 4 Invisible Woman Marcia Higgins (who was absent from the October 7th meeting), will be replaced by Jack Eaton. Anyone who has followed Eaton’s campaign for office during the primary election season knows that he favors an ethics policy that avoids even the appearance of impropriety, and finds McWilliams’s proposed appointment unacceptable for a number of reasons.

It’s probable, then, that unless McWilliams withdraws his name he will find himself the subject of a Council resolution which demands he step down given that his nomination did not get the required eight votes on September 16th. McWilliams and Hieftje could continue with the pretense that McWilliams is actually a member of the DDA Board (he has attended meetings already). They might even claim McWilliams should be afforded the opportunity for a public hearing. Alas, that will mean that everyone will have the opportunity to speak, including Council members and the public. That may not be what either John Hieftje or Albert Mcwilliams wants, because either Council members or the members of the public could read from McWilliams’s own blog, show the photos he had posted or repeat his Tweets—all to stunning effect. Though McWilliams attempted to delete or hide the offending materials sometime after the September 3rd Council meeting, many who visited his sites prior to his efforts to cleanse them obviously took computer screen shots.

It’s worth noting that during public commentary resident Peter Zetlin reported to Council that he’d spoken to Maura Thompson, the Director of the Main Street Association about her personal endorsement of McWilliams, as well as the endorsement of the Main Street Association. Zetlin reported that when asked if she and her organization stood behind McWilliams as the best candidate for the position, Thompson had refused to answer the question.

“Perhaps,” Zetlin posited, “she didn’t answer because she’s embarrassed.”

Also during public commentary, Ann Arbor resident Mary Underwood stunned the dozens of people in Council chambers by simply ending her measured and thoughtful public comments about the McWilliams appointment with a quote from Albert McWilliams’s own Twitter account: “Shove an ice cream cone up your ass.”

The gasps from those present were audible, and several people muttered that McWilliams did not, indeed, seem the best choice to sit on the Board of the DDA. John Hieftje, who’d made a joke about “profanity on the Internet” when defending McWilliams on September 3rd, turned several shades of red, and stared wide-eyed at Underwood, obviously mortified. Council member Jane Lumm, stunned, put her hand over her mouth and shook her head slowly.

Ward 1 Council member Sabra Briere, who’d justified her tie-breaking vote in favor of McWilliams’s proposed appointment by saying she’d read through the allegedly offensive materials and had found nothing that bothered her, found very important things to read on her computer screen as Underwood left the podium. Maybe, just maybe, Briere was pondering what she should do with the ice cream in her freezer at home.

At the end of the October 7th Council meeting, McWilliams nomination was “reopened” in order to consider it at the final Council meeting in October. One imagines Hieftje is planning to try to sort out the mess he made. He’d do better to get to the store and stock up on antacids. 

Ward 1 Independent Challenger Snags Support From Council Dems
Ward 1 City Council challenger Jeff Hayner has landed the quiet support of several City Council Democrats. Ward 2 City Council incumbent Jane Lumm has the unabashed support of several ...
READ MORE
Four Years Later Ethics Problems Still Haunt EMU Governmental Relations Director
The only former Ann Arbor City Council member having a worse time of it politically than Downtown Development Authority Board member Joan Lowenstein (former Ward 2 Council member) is former ...
READ MORE
Still Pulling Strings: “Baby” Leigh Chairs Ypsi DDA and “Writes the Script” For AA Pols Via Email
by P.D. Lesko "This job has been extremely rewarding but also extremely stressful," he says. "I have no future political plans. I am looking forward to time off. I am looking ...
READ MORE
Ward 1 Sabra Briere Gets A Challenger for City Council Seat
by P.D. Lesko At the 4th of July parade as the Backwards Clown Brigade chuckled along the parade route, a man seated on the curb turned to his wife and said, ...
READ MORE
Playing the “Progressive Values” Card While Pushing ALEC-Inspired Scams & Parkland Development Schemes
by P.D. Lesko Ward 2 Democratic City Council candidate Kirk Westphal moved to Ann Arbor in 2004 and in 2006 was appointed by John Hieftje to the city's Planning Commission. It ...
READ MORE
Ward 1 Independent Challenger Snags Support From Council
Four Years Later Ethics Problems Still Haunt EMU
Still Pulling Strings: “Baby” Leigh Chairs Ypsi DDA
Ward 1 Sabra Briere Gets A Challenger for
Playing the “Progressive Values” Card While Pushing ALEC-Inspired

Short URL: http://www.a2politico.com/?p=15408

10 Comments for “Council Members Refuse To Back Away From Public Protest of Mayoral Nominee”

  1. The mayor should be hung!

    • Better yet, the Mayor should inaugurate McWilliams’ Election Day advice as a city tradition every November.

      And send a complimentary gallon of French vanilla Haagen-Dazs with an amply supply of cones from Washtenaw Dairy as a gift to the Mayor and his fellow DDA board members.

      • I think Mark Karoi is on to something there! A little ice cream could go a long way in helping the public feel good about McWilliams. Poor Al complained to Ryan Stanton that he is being bullied. Maybe someone should give him a gallon of French vanilla. If he is stupid enough to write this garbage for the public to see it shouldn’t surprise him if people react to it.

    • Al McWilliams asks, “The mayor should be hung, but is he?”

  2. A word about my presentation to council last night: The combination of violation of council procedures, questionable ethics in taking conflicts of interest seriously, council members perhaps not fully doing their homework, a person of questionable character appointed to a very powerful committee in town with a lasting influence on those of us who live here, and yes, language and photo content on Mr. McWilliams’ blog churned into the perfect storm. I decided to be the “mother”, mentioned so many times in several council members’ objections to McWilliams, who would drop dead of a heart attack if happening on Mr. McWilliams’ very open-to-the-public web blog. Who’s charged with keeping Mom off of the internet? The most objectionable word is last, should the city possess a means of bleeping out offensive content.
    A word in Mr. McWilliams’ defense. Along with the blog rants I read by Mr. McWilliams, I also read an interview done right after he made the first cut. http://www.mlive.com/news/ann-arbor/index.ssf/2013/09/al_mcwilliams_ann_arbor_dda.html
    I found myself in line with much of Mr. McWilliams had to say and support, as stated in this interview. Not sure how much was filtered…. Does that make him the best choice for the DDA? Not really. All my life I’ve been a volunteer in various local, state, and national organizations, including the former Ann Arbor Bicycle Coordination Committee (an appointee of the mayor). I know how hard it is to find capable people willing to serve on committees and do the necessary work to run organizations, instead of pedaling off for a beer with buddies in one’s precious free time. Mr. McWilliams appears to have much to offer. But maybe not now. He’s already grown up, so let’s not keep expecting that. But Al, put away the clown hat if you want to serve in something besides a circus. Even the former actor, Leslie Nielsen, master of fart jokes, would manage some self-censoring if holding public office. Surely he would manage that. Please make that be true.

  3. A word about my presentation to council last night: The combination of violation of council procedures, questionable ethics in taking conflicts of interest seriously, council members perhaps not fully doing their homework, a person of questionable character appointed to a very powerful committee in town with a lasting influence on those of us who live here, and yes, language and photo content on Mr. McWilliams’ blog churned into the perfect storm. I decided to be the “mother”, mentioned so many times in several council members’ objections to McWilliams, who would drop dead of a heart attack if happening on Mr. McWilliams’ very open-to-the-public web blog. Who’s charged with keeping Mom off of the internet? The most objectionable word is last, should the city possess a means of bleeping out offensive content.

    A word in Mr. McWilliams’ defense. Along with the blog rants I read by Mr. McWilliams,
    I also read an interview done right after he made the first cut. http://www.mlive.com/news/ann-arbor/index.ssf/2013/09/al_mcwilliams_ann_arbor_dda.html
    I found myself inline with much of Mr. McWilliams had to say and support, as stated in this interview. Not sure how much was filtered…. Does that make him the best choice for the DDA? Not really. All my life I’ve been a volunteer in various local, state, and national organizations, including the former Ann Arbor Bicycle Coordination Committee (an appointee of the mayor).

    I know how hard it is to find capable people willing to serve on committees and do the necessary work to run organizations, instead of pedaling off for a beer with buddies in one’s precious free time. Mr. McWilliams appears to have much to offer. But maybe not now. He’s already grown up, so let’s not keep expecting that. But Al, put away the clown hat if you want to serve in something besides a circus. Even the former actor, Leslie Nielsen, master of fart jokes, would manage some self-censoring if holding public office. Surely he would manage that. Please make that be true.

  4. It’s probable, then, that unless McWilliams withdraws his name he will find himself the subject of a Council resolution which demands he step down given that his nomination did not get the required eight votes on September 16th.

    a2politico – I certainly hope council defenders of McWilliams come to their senses for the next meeting. However, this morning WEMU aired souncilman Kunsleman saying he thinks it’s likely that the appointment will stand. It was disturbing to hear him state this.

    • The appointment likely will stand as City Attorney Steve Postema pointed out that the appointment has already been “partially executed” since McWilliams has apparently already assumed and performed duties as a board member of the DDA and thereby barring a reconsideration motion.

      McWilliams can only be removed for cause after a public hearing on the matter – that is very unlikely.

      Many of Hietje’s cronies have resigned. Take Eric Sturgis on the Taxicab Board after absenteeism.

      What should be done is City Council should crack down on these last-minute agenda nominations and put future prospective appointees through a rigorous process.

  5. Just to clarify this part: “Peter Zetlin reported to Council that he’d spoken to Maura Thompson, ” I didn’t call Ms. Thompson. Instead, I emailed her and she did not answer.

    Thanks for the good and rapid reporting.

  6. I was considering going to City Council chambers to deliver commentary on this issue but am glad I did not – as I could not add anything more to the sterling presentations of Mary Underwood and Peter Zetlin. They succinctly said it all.

    Remember the other recent Hieftje appointee to the DDA who sat next to Hizzoner at the board meetings? The attorney Nader Nassif. The Al McWilliams story actually dwarfed the fact that today Nassif was scheduled to face a preliminary examination of 3rd degree criminal sexual conduct, plus the prosecution indicated they were going to add counts of ecstasy, cocaine and marijuana possession. He is 29-year old and 2 years ago his law firm received a six-figure legal services contract with the City of Ann Arbor – just after his DDA appointment; City Council approves his firm’s legal fee requests and hence has great potential leverage over his prior voting on the DDA.

    Nassif was a big donor to Judge Timothy Connors’ circuit court election campaign last year and posed for a photo taken in Connors’ courtroom seat wearing a black robe. Nassif had that much clout with the judiciary – not to mention the Mayor and City Council.

    What in blazes is going on with Hieftje and these immature schmucks he appoints to high office?

Leave a Reply

Recently Commented

  • George Anderson: Yes, one more. How dumb do you have to be to answer the question that way?... %comment_rating
  • Trish: I am so glad I found this, today my daughter left to live with her father, my son already... %comment_rating
  • Jackie: I really needed this today. Like many of you I go back and forth between guilt, sadness and... %comment_rating
  • Bianca: Ladies, keep your chins up. It takes a strong mother to actually do what’s best for the... %comment_rating